Manager feedback · 2 scenarios · live voice

Manager feedback practice, out loud, against someone who pushes back

Underperformance, a missed deadline, behaviour that is affecting the team. Practise saying the thing plainly, on the day, without it becoming either a soft chat that changes nothing or a confrontation.

Built for L&D and people teams. Every call is spoken in real time — not a chat transcript — and ends with a scored debrief you can replay.

What you are scored on

These are the four axes the debrief grades, written out in full rather than summarised. Knowing them before the call is not cheating — it is the difference between practice and a test.

Clarity of the message

Did the person leave in no doubt about what specifically needs to change? Softening that obscures the message is the most common failure in this conversation.

Specific evidence

Was the feedback anchored in observable behaviour and dated examples, rather than characterisation ('you seem disengaged') or second-hand report?

Two-way handling

Did they listen to the response and adjust where there was genuinely new information, without abandoning the message when it got uncomfortable?

Result

Did it end with a shared understanding of what changes, by when, and what happens next — or with the manager relieved it was over?

How the call can end

The counterpart is not scripted to agree. Each of these is a real outcome the scenario can reach, ordered best to worst.

Understood, change agreed

win

The message landed, was accepted, and there is a specific agreement.

Heard but defensive

partial

It landed and was not accepted. Better than most managers achieve.

Softened away

loss

The message got so padded that the person left thinking they were doing fine. The most common way this conversation fails.

Became a confrontation

loss

It turned adversarial and nothing was agreed.

The scenarios

Other things to practise

Take a manager feedback call

The conversation managers avoid for months. A real voice on the other end, a counterpart who does not simply agree, and a scored debrief against the four axes above. The first call is free.